Don’t blame developers for poor doors – blame Britain’s planning laws
5 August 2014 8:28pm
"POOR doors” have been slammed on newspaper front pages in recent weeks – stories of luxury developments in New York with separate entrances for on-site affordable housing have spread across the Atlantic, as it turns out that there are similar arrangements in London too.
The outrage this discovery has provoked is understandable. Though the practice is not new, it seems to represent a chilling segregation in the heart of our cities, as wealthy residents get to use swanky entrances at the front, while affordable housing tenants are asked to enter through another door of the same building. But it’s important that the blame is fairly attributed. In the UK, a combination of our warped planning system and the law surrounding tenancies makes the reasoning behind this strange construction decision much easier to understand.
In the US, campaigners are angry because attaching affordable units means developers get a carrot for building them – a tax break. In the UK, it’s a stick: build the units, through something called a section 106 agreement with the local authority, or no planning permission at all.
But the bevy of staff and services that come attached to expensive properties are not included in the asking price, and could mean huge bills for tenants in low-rent flats. Developers are afraid of legal action if they allow private tenants in luxury apartments to cross-subsidise the service charges of affordable housing tenants, so separate entrances are constructed to let the latter avoid regular hefty fees.
Yet the perverse implications of section 106 agreements go much further. When economist Kate Barker wrote her seminal report on the inadequate British planning system, Barratt told her that major developments now take over a year to approve – four to five times what was required in the early 1980s, with section 106 talks named specifically as one of the factors which could slow down development.
And if protracted negotiations do retard development, it’s clear where they would do so most. More than half of all affordable housing units agreed through section 106 in 2011-12 were in London. The average local authority in London agreed the construction of 643 units with developers – ten times as many as the rest of urban England.
Further, given the current system, it’s not necessarily clear whether the alternative to so-called poor doors is any better. As The New York Times’s Josh Barro has noted: “Nobody complains about the poor door when it’s located four blocks away from the rich door.” If using separate doors to access the same building is bad, is having entirely separate buildings for affordable housing worse? Some developers have avoided this furore, as they were able to provide their quota of affordable housing on a different site entirely.
Ultimately, there’s only one real solution to Britain’s housing affordability crisis: build more homes. London councils rightly say that the city needs massive additional house building – something like 800,000 units over the next seven years. In 2013, only 11,460 permanent housing units were completed by private enterprise in London. Even if each one came with a section 106 agreement for five additional affordable units, the city would be nowhere near its target.
In other news
Sepp Blatter will be Fifa president for a further four years after comfortably beating Prince Ali Bin Al-Hussein [Read more]
Ukip's Lord Pearson of Rannoch has asked the government to back a draw Mohammed competition. [Read more]
Network Rail and RMT bosses are once again entering talks to see if the latest set of strikes, announced yesterday, [Read more]
IMF chief Christine Lagarde said this morning that a comprehensive deal with Greece is "very unlikely... in the next few days". [Read more]
Good news multiple-gun salute fans. Next week there will be not one but two such events, marking the 62nd year [Read more]
An EasyJet flight from Luton to Tel Aviv has been forced to turn back after multiple cabin crew members reported [Read more]
A vehicle has struck a bridge it was passing under in Tulse Hill, south London, causing train cancellations and [Read more]
Shares in troubled insurance claims outsourcer Quindell fell in late morning trading after the company announced [Read more]
After a number of top Fifa officials were arrested on accusations of bribery and racketeering this week, the already [Read more]
The mother of the children who died at a Thomas Cook-approved hotel in Corfu has slammed Harriet Green's decision [Read more]
The meteoric rise in London office rents is unlikely to slow down for at least another year, the chief executive [Read more]
Andy Burnham will today admit that Labour got it wrong on business and the economy, and that the party cannot [Read more]
The German Chambers of Commerce and Industry has said it is “astonished” that the UK is considering leaving [Read more]
When it comes to creating new technologies, London is a long way behind other cities in the UK, new research has [Read more]
Four FinTech startups have won $100,000 (£65,400) backing from Citi after a search for new technology and innovation [Read more]
Property types may have been worried about the looming spectre of a mansion tax during the run-up to the General [Read more]
Corruption allegations, arrests of top officials, global outrage - in most organisations such calamities would [Read more]
Are the UK's new crop of MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Donmar Warehouse | ★★★★★ [Read more]
Olivier Theatre | ★★★☆☆
Kingfisher, Europe’s biggest home improvement retailer, said it has found buyers for a quarter of its stores [Read more]
Clothing retailer Abercrombie & Fitch said yesterday that its business is recovering, buoyed by the strong [Read more]
Just a handful of football clubs offer fans fast smartphone connections despite growing pressure to install the [Read more]