Corporation tax: Why it’s workers who really pay when we squeeze firms
17 March 2014 4:03am
WHEN One Direction (1D) weighed in on the corporation tax debate, calling on their fans to pressure George Osborne into “cracking down on company tax avoidance”, it was the clearest indication yet that business tax has become a popular issue. But what has not filtered through to the public debate is the question of who bears the economic burden of this tax – is it fat cats, or could it secretly come out of wages or turn up in higher prices?
If this is confusing, this is because, for economists, a tax’s burden is borne by who it makes worse off. For example, though shops hand over VAT to HMRC, it is generally accepted that consumers bear the burden through higher prices. And while employers hand over national insurance contributions, economists tend to think this money comes at the expense of lower wage offers than there would otherwise be.
Since companies are just legal constructs, they cannot bear any of the burden of corporation tax themselves. Instead, the most likely burden-bearers are workers, who may get lower wages, consumers, who might face higher prices, or shareholders, who might receive lower dividends or see their shares worth less.
1D may be surprised to discover that, according to the empirical studies I have pored over in my research, it is workers, not capitalists, who suffer most when corporation tax rises. Even excluding the highest results to get a very conservative estimate, I found that, according to the average empirical research paper, 57.6 per cent of the burden of corporation tax is borne by workers in the form of lower wages.
This exclusion is important, because some well-cited papers find a much higher result. According to Kevin Hassett and Aparna Mathur’s 2006 paper, causing firms to pay an extra $1 in tax leads to approximately $22 less paid in wages, effectively a burden of 2,200 per cent. R Alison Felix’s 2007 paper found that 400 per cent of the size of a change in corporation tax revenues came out of worker pay.
How does this happen? First, higher corporation tax means less profit for firms and workers to bargain over. Second, higher corporation tax means less relative reason to tie up investment in capital as opposed to consuming it in general, and in particular less relative reason to tie up investment in capital in a given country. Less capital per worker means lower productivity, and lower productivity means lower wages.
There are endless complications and the debate is ongoing – while the empirical estimates of the worker share I found ranged from 0 per cent to 2,200 per cent, some theoretical results thought workers might even benefit.
But if anything, this is an extra reason to be sceptical about corporation tax – we aren’t even sure who pays it. If it turns out not to be a stealth tax on workers, it’s a capital tax, which economists almost unanimously believe is a particularly distortionary and inefficient way to raise revenue.
At best, corporation tax is a stealth tax on workers. At worst, it is a highly distortionary investment-reducing capital tax. In this week’s Budget, the chancellor is expected to cut it 1 percentage point: he should go much further. Let’s hope it doesn’t take a petition from 1D fans to convince him.
Ben Southwood is head of policy at the Adam Smith Institute. His paper Who Pays Corporation Tax is out today.
In other news
Pharma giant GSK (aka GlaxoSmithKline) has abandoned plans for an IPO of its HIV medicines division, it said today. [Read more]
What happens if you spray unsuspecting spiders with graphene, the world's strongest artificial material? They [Read more]
The British trader accused of causing the U.S. 2010 flash crash cannot pay his £5m bail because U.S. authorities [Read more]
Fragments of a failed Russian spacecraft are expected to fall to Earth later this week, according to space agency [Read more]
With just one day left of campaigning, the polls indicate there's little between the main parties, which suggests the [Read more]
It's not hard to tell the difference between Skype and Sky. One's a Microsoft-owned text, voice and video messaging [Read more]
In the aftermath of the subprime mortgage crisis, you'd have thought lenders had learned their lessons - but perhaps [Read more]
Sales at discounters Aldi and Lidl grew 15 per cent and 10 per cent respectively in the past year, data published [Read more]
The last data released before the polls open tomorrow has shown services growth hit an eight-month high, potentially [Read more]
If you share a heartbeat and there's no one at the other end to feel it, has that heartbeat been shared at all? [Read more]
We all know staying on top of emails is a challenge, and that's without the added pressure of coming up with a [Read more]
Londoners spend 12 hours a day online, a new study suggests - three hours more than the average UK resident. [Read more]
Network Rail has confirmed there will be delays into and out of London Waterloo station until "at least 9.30am" [Read more]
This is supposed to be the "social election" - but are the UK's MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Pub and restaurant group Greene King yesterday blamed recently tightened drink-driving laws in Scotland for flat [Read more]
Bargain store Poundland has bought forward a competition probe into its offer to buy rival 99p Stores for £55m. [Read more]
It may be at a “great disadvantage” to supermarkets, but JD Wetherspoon still managed to report an increase [Read more]
It is difficult to believe that it was half a decade ago that Liam Byrne – a Treasury minister in Gordon Brown’s [Read more]
Shares in Salesforce.com jumped 6.2 per cent yesterday, after it was reported that Microsoft is considering [Read more]
Nick Clegg has warned that the country could be forced to hold a second election before Christmas, if his party [Read more]
The global economy risks slipping into a deflationary trap. The US recovery is built on shaky ground, the Eurozone [Read more]
Business has led the recovery in recent years, but this cannot be taken for granted. We need an environment that [Read more]
SHOP PRICES continued to fall in April, albeit at a slower pace, with food prices remaining at a record low for [Read more]