As Tube strikes cause transport chaos, should such union action be restricted?

YES
“The most conservative man in the world is the British trade unionist when you want to change him.” The words of an ardent capitalist? No, it was Ernest Bevin, founding member of the Transport and General Workers Union. This week’s Tube strikes by the RMT show this resistance to change lives on. Businesses that don’t adapt to developments in technology and customer need will wither and die, and the London Underground is not immune. If a better and more cost-effective service can be delivered by unshackling staff from their ticket booths, then modernisation should not be resisted by union leadership. Industrial action on this vital part of our national infrastructure cannot be allowed to drag on. Now is the time to reform the law so that a majority of balloted union members must vote in favour of a strike. Ballot papers should also specify the number of strike days, with unions forced to hold a further vote if they want to take the workforce out on strike again. Simon Walker is director general of the Institute of Directors.
No
Tube strikes are inconvenient, aggravating, and cost Londoners millions of pounds. But specific government intervention into the employment contracts of Tube workers is not the solution. The ability to go on strike in Britain is already limited. Laws intervening in contracts further are likely to go awry by preventing the market from discovering the best employment arrangements – the optimal number of strikes may not be zero. And intervention in the contracts of a particular firm or sector, like London transport workers, is open to the worst kinds of abuse by politicians with an axe to grind or a donor to satisfy. The state should be neutral in trade disputes, neither protecting unions nor curbing them. In an ideal world, of course, the taxpayer would not subsidise the Underground. Perhaps Transport for London should ultimately automate the whole Tube – but that is for TfL’s managers and the GLA to decide. Sam Bowman is research director at the Adam Smith Institute.

Simon Walker

Simon Walker is director general of the Institute of Directors.

Wednesday 04 June 2014
NOTHING baffles me more than the complaint that government isn’t doing enough.
Tuesday 13 May 2014
THERE was something quite uncomfortable about watching MPs do their best to trip up the boss of a major multinational that has expressed an interest in investing in the UK economy.
Tuesday 01 April 2014
LIKE several hundred thousand other ordinary investors, I emerged from Royal Mail’s flotation with 227 shares in my Isa. I don’t normally apply for Initial Public Offerings (IPO), and this one certainly didn’t come without risks.
Wednesday 29 August 2012
AIRPORTS are an umbilical cord for the economy – tourism, inward investment and export opportunities all flow into Britain through them. Any constriction, or lack in capacity, has a harmful effect, limiting our potential for growth.
Thursday 24 May 2012
DEBATE has raged for days over Adrian Beecroft’s proposed employment law reforms, exposing some fundamental problems in our politics.
Thursday 03 May 2012
HEATHROW’S immigration queue crisis is already a national embarrassment, but the true scale of the damage it is doing has yet to be recognised.
Thursday 22 March 2012
DIRECTOR GENERAL
Wednesday 29 February 2012
THE UK’s higher education sector is an export success story. Only the United States recruits more international students.
Thursday 24 November 2011
IN RECENT days, the implications of the EU regulatory reform agenda for the City of London have been widely reported. However, the financial sector is not the only area of vulnerability to future EU directives.

Sam Bowman

Sam Bowman is research director at the Adam Smith Institute.

Wednesday 28 May 2014
WHEN the man behind the Segway, the battery-powered personal mobility scooter, died after riding one of his products off a cliff, it seemed like a grim end to yet another transport fad.
Tuesday 22 April 2014
WHISPER it, but things finally seem to be looking up. Investment is rising, unemployment is falling, and the deficit seems to be coming under control. But it could be a lot better. Real wages will not recover to their pre-crisis peak until 2020.
Tuesday 04 February 2014
RENTS are rising, pushing people on low incomes out of the neighbourhoods they’ve lived in for years. Resentment towards the rich is growing, with the most profitable and dynamic industries singled out for the most ire.
Wednesday 23 October 2013
THE PHRASE “papers, please” once conjured up the image of a totalitarian dystopia, where anyone might rat out their neighbour to the government. Britons have always been allergic to this informant culture – a hallmark of the unlimited state.
Thursday 20 June 2013
THE final report of Parliament’s commission into banking standards recommends many (often contradictory) things, but running through it is the theme that the industry suffered from a cultural failure.
Tuesday 16 April 2013
THE One Direction backlash has begun. Yesterday, critics reportedly dubbed the boy band’s £25m earnings last year “insensitive” and “grossly immoral”.
Thursday 02 August 2012
WHEN Napoleon Bonaparte’s regime executed an aristocrat on trumped-up charges of treason, stirring up bloody memories of the Revolution, his chief of police is said to have remarked that it was “worse than a crime; it was a blunder”.
Monday 19 September 2011
MORE people have climbed out of poverty in the past 50 years than did so in the 500 years before that. Life expectancies across the world have doubled in the last one hundred years.

City A.M.'s Opinion pages are a place for thought-provoking opinions and views. These are not necessarily shared by City A.M.

Show Comments

In Other News