Osborne's claims that Scotland couldn't use the pound don't stack up
13 February 2014 10:54am
Chancellor George Osborne is on the warpath this morning.
He's knocking the idea of Scotland using the pound, without asking England's permission. Something that Adam Smith Institute research director Sam Bowman says the English government couldn't stop it doing.
Pointing to other countries that do something similar - Panama with the dollar, and Montenegro with the euro - Osborne said that they're not "the two strongest precedents or the countries you'd want to follow".
Panama as precedent?
Those examples both come from "Scotland analysis: Assessment of a sterling currency union". But Osborne's criticism of them is unfounded.
Panama is one of the world's fastest growing countries. According to the World Bank the economy "did relatively well during the global financial crisis" when compared with "other countries in the region", with 3.2 per cent growth in 2009.
In 2010 the economy resumed its growth rate with an increase of 7.6%, and growing 10.6% in 2011, 10% in 2012.
Panama is "the most competitive economy in Central America, and second in Latin America" according to the 2013-14 World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Report.
It would be hard to come to the conclusion that Panama is a bad example unless you have some kind of prejudice against Latin American economies.
And looking at Panama's capital, Panama City, it's certainly difficult to conclude that it's any kind of basket case.
Osborne's more serious contentions - that by entering a sterlingzone Scotland would have no control over its monetary policy, would have no lender of last resort, and no control of its money supply - deserve more attention.
Government analysis says that other countries who use the currency of another end up having no influence over monetary policy - with Panama and Montenegro having "no influence over [the] US ... or influence over at the European Central Bank" respectively.
But for a country like a newly independent Scotland - the issues Osborne highglights don't seem to play out.
Last December ratings agency Moody's said that becoming a dollarized economy "has ensured macroeconomic stability."
For the stability of its banks Panama ranks seventh in the world out of 148 countries according to the aforementioned World Economic Forum report.
Lack of monetary control?
It's true that Scotland would have no power over monetary policy - but do many think that Scotland gets much consideration from the Bank of England at present?
The Scottish population stands at around 5.3m of a total United Kingdom figure of 63.2m.
Lender of last resort?
Economist George Selgin has pointed out that not having a lender of last resort has actually been a positive for dollarized economies as "by doing away with, or at least greatly limiting, any prospect of a bailout, it has caused creditors and banks to behave more prudently.
In other news
Graduates should be awarded point scores alongside the existing degree grades, a new report has said, something [Read more]
Banks are finally starting to lend to Britain's small and medium sized businesses new data has shown, suggesting [Read more]
Just eight years ago, there was no iPhone, while a mere decade ago, half of all Britain's internet connections [Read more]
The nationwide rail strike, called off at the 11th hour last week, has been rescheduled for next week. [Read more]
Women's teams will feature on the forthcoming Fifa '16 video games - marking the first time women's football has [Read more]
Just a day after the Queen's Speech confirmed what we knew the Tories would have to do, a bill has dropped into [Read more]
Avago Technologies has sealed a $37bn acquisition of fellow semiconductor company Broadcom to create an industry [Read more]
Russian President Vladimir Putin has accused the United States of meddling in affairs beyond its jurisdiction [Read more]
The UK's GDP increased by 0.3 per cent in the first quarter of 2015, according to the latest figures from the [Read more]
Five people were arrested after the anti-austerity protest in Whitehall and Trafalgar Square turned voilent yesterday. [Read more]
Claire Perry has said “at times, the delays and disruption that are occurring are simply inexcusable.” [Read more]
Like electing a boss of Fifa whose surname isn’t Blatter or extracting an apology from Thomas Cook, reforming [Read more]
Britain's FinTech sector is a particularly bright spot in the UK’s recovering economy. Investment in London [Read more]
Currency volatility did Kingfisher no favours in the first quarter of 2015, but investors have not been put off. [Read more]
Power systems manufacturer Rolls-Royce has signed an €80m (£57m) contract with General Dynamics European Land [Read more]