Watchdog sets out plans to shake up accountancy
23 July 2013 1:57am
THE COMPETITION Commission has stopped short of forcing companies to regularly change their auditor, in a package of planned reforms that has split the accountancy profession.
Smaller auditors yesterday called for the watchdog to go further, while the so-called Big Four firms warned of the red tape that could come with plans to force FTSE 350 companies to put their audit contracts out to tender at least every five years.
The Competition Commission’s provisional plans to open up the audit market also include a ban on firms using “Big Four Only” clauses in loan contracts, and giving investors a vote on whether a firm’s yearly audit committee report is informative enough.
The watchdog also wants to make the pitching process more transparent, to ensure smaller firms are not excluded.
The proposals are less radical than the reforms being debated by the European Union, but go beyond the measures introduced by the Financial Reporting Council earlier this year.
The FRC and several larger auditors raised concerns that the CC’s plans will increase costs.
“[Mandatory tendering] is not in the public interest and will likely only serve to increase the financial burden on companies at a time of ongoing economic uncertainty,” said Hywel Bell, managing partner for assurance at EY.
But many smaller firms called for more action to grant them access to the market. Ninety-nine firms in the FTSE 100 use one of the Big Four for their audits, with many using the same auditor for other consultancy work.
“We have just been through our worst financial crisis for generations and there is a public expectation that robust audit reform will be high on the agenda. Further action is needed to create a level playing field for new entrants into the FTSE 350 market,” said David Herbinet, head of public interest markets at Mazars.
The Commission’s final report is due by October.
In other news
Last night hundreds of people in Kent were woken by a 4.2 magnitude earthquake, which occurred just before 3am. [Read more]
Are the UK's new crop of MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Newly re-elected Prime minister David Cameron will hold his first talks with European Union leaders today, as [Read more]
The Conservatives came to power on the back of an improving economy and with the promise of more improvement to [Read more]
Individual train operators say services are back on track as Network Rail blasts "deplorable" strike threat. [Read more]
Hewlett Packard (HP) announced disappointing earnings this afternoon, with revenues missing analysts expectations. [Read more]
In pictures: National waiters day kicks off with race around Hyde Park. [Read more]
Thomas Cook has revealed Georgios Chrysikopoulos, the general manager of the hotel in Corfu where children Christianne [Read more]
It's no surprise that we take to social media to vent our frustration when commuting, but a new report has shed [Read more]
Britain is losing billions each year from UK residents spending their money abroad on holidays, while overseas [Read more]
Waiting staff are out on protest today in central London over low pay and claims that Pizza Express management [Read more]
Sajid Javid’s new enterprise bill, announced this week in Bristol, is certainly well intentioned, but it's unlikely [Read more]
Just as Prime Minister David Cameron outlined his stance on tackling immigration, figures were published showing [Read more]
Bright-eyed graduates eager to train at one of London's leading law firms may have to stomach long hours, however [Read more]
With candidates lining up to take over Ed Miliband as the new Labour leader, divisions in the party are appearing [Read more]
There's no easy way to say this, but it sounds like there's going to be a global shortage of Prosecco this summer. [Read more]
Since early 2013, when Japan’s QE became imminent, its average quarterly annualised GDP growth rate has risen [Read more]