Time for the coalition to abandon its obsession with mutuals
18 June 2013 3:23am
REMEMBER all those people who, just a few months ago, were proclaiming that mutuals were the answer, and had to be encouraged to improve the diversity of the UK banking system? We were told that firms owned by their workers or employers would be better, safer and more pro-consumer than the nasty old Plcs. It was all nonsense, as this newspaper argued forcibly and unfashionably at the time.
The confirmation that the Co-operative Group will be forced to list its banking unit on the stock market, as part of its bail-in, means that it will no longer be a pure mutual in any meaningful sense of that word. While the deal means that the Co-op bank is now safe, this is a humiliation not just for that organisation, with its proud history, but also for all those politicians – including Tories and Liberal Democrats – who peddled all of that extreme pro-mutual nonsense.
Don’t get me wrong: in some cases, mutuals might be the best possible business model. They may well work better than charities in providing certain kinds of services, for example, though it’s hard to test that proposition given the current tax rules, which favour charities. The mutual model was wrongly squeezed out by the state during the twentieth century: the friendly society movement used to do wonders providing extensive unemployment and health insurance, and pensions, to the working poor.
In banking, some building societies continue to succeed – though their number is much reduced – not least the Nationwide, which has emerged very well from the credit crisis. My problem is that such success stories are rare, and with financial services now a hugely capital-intensive business, the ability to tap the public markets to raise additional equity if necessary has become a major advantage. Mutuals cannot do this, which puts them at a major disadvantage and in some cases might even make them riskier.
Given all of that, the idea that employee or member ownership is self-evidently a superior model was clearly a case of ideologically-driven delusion, an attempt at third way “triangulation” between the for-profit, shareholder owned model and the socialised, public sector approach. It was confused drivel, as stupid as the idea that investment banks are higher risk than retail banks (they are not), or that retail banks with investment banking arms are in a uniquely dangerous position – neither Bradford and Bingley, Northern Rock nor HBOS were investment banks, and Co-op is the exact opposite of one. In fact, all the evidence suggests that large, diversified universal banks are less risky, but try telling that to the purveyors of the conventional wisdom.
One of the most fascinating questions of corporate governance is why John Lewis continues to do so well, despite being an employee-owned business. This deserves to be studied endlessly at business schools. No other major company in the world with a similar corporate structure is as successful and innovative. Normally, shareholder-owned, for profit companies are more efficient, more motivated, more agile and better able to raise capital. John Lewis is the exception that proves the rule.
But the government never saw any of this, believing that everybody could be like John Lewis – even though the very opposite is true, and that nobody else can be. The good news is that the Co-op’s conversion to the merits of the stock exchange will now hopefully rejuvenate it, and allow it back on the path of growth. Its bail-in – the conversion of bonds to equity – also shows that the reforms of the past few years, and the introduction of new resolution procedures to recapitalise institutions without taxpayer money, is working. What a shame the government has wasted so much time and energy pursuing a policy that was always an irrelevant distraction.
Follow me on Twitter: @allisterheath
In other news
There were delays of up to 30 minutes to trains in and out of Kings Cross Station, after the station was re-opened [Read more]
When a 20-year-old footballer publicly declares he wants to leave a club and his agent hurls insults at one of [Read more]
The outbreak of bird flu in the US is leading to an unprecedented situation for companies reliant on eggs – [Read more]
Germany's finance ministry has denied reports it was considering offering Greece its own parallel currency. [Read more]
Chancellor George Osborne was given a boost today, as higher tax receipts helped shrink the deficit by more than [Read more]
Beleaguered spread-betting firm Plus500 today suspended trading in its shares on London's junior market, following [Read more]
The news that card and electronic transactions have overtaken cash as the UK’s preferred method of payment is [Read more]
Despite the crippling effect of election uncertainty, offers received in April were up 15 per cent on last year [Read more]
Former secretary of state for communities and local government Eric Pickles is to be knighted, 10 Downing Street [Read more]
Network Rail engineers have destroyed the Abbey Wood station as part of the Crossrail development that is expected [Read more]
The Championship looks set to once again be named the fourth most-watched league in Europe, following a seven [Read more]
The Costa Coffee owner said Brittain was "the standout candidate from a very strong field". [Read more]
Sugary foods may be taxed to cover the costs of treating obesity, a government minister has said.
European governments must increase efforts to adopt structural reform if “lasting stability and prosperity” [Read more]
Accounting, finance and economics - choose to study any of these subjects anywhere and you'll be likely to land [Read more]
Badly-behaved bosses are a nightmare if you're the unfortunate employee who has to work for them - but they're [Read more]