Is Sir Martin Sorrell right that corporation tax payments are a “question of judgement”?
3 January 2013 12:49am
As the public becomes increasingly aware of how much tax companies are paying, chief executives should be asking: “What impact will our tax affairs have on our brand?” Sir Martin Sorrell is right to acknowledge that Starbucks’s decision to pay £20m extra in corporation tax was motivated by the idea that “doing good is good business”. But this highlights a broader issue: the UK has a tax gap of over £32bn a year – the equivalent of seven government departments’ annual budgets. Taxation must be simplified in response to increasing international and online business, and HMRC must be properly resourced to tackle avoidance. Britain must be fair to all businesses, including small firms. The current position distorts competition and ultimately leaves individual taxpayers to make up the shortfall.
Steve Barclay is a Conservative MP for North East Cambridgeshire and a member of the Public Accounts Committee.
I disagree with Sir Martin Sorrell’s claim, which is based on the perception that capital can locate where it wishes and can move at will. Three things perpetuate this myth. The first is that tax havens (and low-tax jurisdictions), whose opacity allows much of the supposed mobility of capital, obscure the reality that often nothing moves bar the ink on a contract. The second is a financial sector that promotes and services this myth. The third is that tax authorities are unwilling – as the Public Accounts Committee has suggested – to tackle tax avoidance. Multinational companies cannot make money without engaging customers, staff, and by employing assets. Paying tax in the right place at the right time is not a moral obligation. The right place is where the customers, staff and assets are. The right time is when the law of the land dictates. It is not “a matter of judgment”; it is a legal obligation.
Richard Murphy is director of Tax Research UK.
In other news
The German Chambers of Commerce and Industry has said it is “astonished” that the UK is considering leaving [Read more]
Sepp Blatter, the controversial 78-year-old Fifa president, is hoping to win a fifth term in today's election, [Read more]
Telecoms group Vodafone has been downgraded by ratings agency Standard & Poors (S&P) which said the company [Read more]
Two of Britain’s biggest banks are both now searching for new corporate brokers, City A.M. understands, in [Read more]
BT Sport is close to announcing a payment structure for subscriptions to its upcoming exclusive live coverage [Read more]
Prime Minister David Cameron put increased pressure on European leaders yesterday to support his EU reform agenda, [Read more]
UK shoppers were slightly less confident this month, but confidence levels remain relatively high, according to [Read more]
Graduates should be awarded point scores alongside the existing degree grades, a new report has said, something [Read more]
Banks are finally starting to lend to Britain's small and medium sized businesses new data has shown, suggesting [Read more]
Just eight years ago, there was no iPhone, while a mere decade ago, half of all Britain's internet connections [Read more]
The nationwide rail strike, called off at the 11th hour last week, has been rescheduled for next week. [Read more]
Women's teams will feature on the forthcoming Fifa '16 video games - marking the first time women's football has [Read more]
Just a day after the Queen's Speech confirmed what we knew the Tories would have to do, a bill has dropped into [Read more]
Avago Technologies has sealed a $37bn acquisition of fellow semiconductor company Broadcom to create an industry [Read more]
Russian President Vladimir Putin has accused the United States of meddling in affairs beyond its jurisdiction [Read more]