It’s time for businesses to abandon lobbying and target voters directly
17 June 2013 7:05am
LOBBYING is once again in the news and a growing number of people believe there is a grand conspiracy between business and politics that is destroying the democratic process. Businesses stand in huge danger of tarnishing their reputations, and the reality is that lobbying rarely helps them achieve their ends. The practice works for politicians, not for business.
There is nothing inherently wrong with lobbying. Politicians need a constant dialogue with industry, charities, and the public sector to ensure the tax and regulatory climate helps them thrive. Nothing hampers creativity and growth like misplaced legislation. Further, in principle, there is no reason why this dialogue cannot take place discreetly if it produces the right results. But we cannot ignore how the actions of some in business and politics give the impression that discreet lobbying creates the conditions for bad behaviour.
Lobbying works as it does not because it suits businesses, but because it suits the way Westminster and Whitehall operate. Most senior executives are happy to discuss problems with proposed new taxes and regulations with practically everyone they meet. Pressure for discretion comes from politicians and their advisers, who make it clear they do not want to face public pressure from businesses that may turn into negative media coverage.
Clearly this discreet approach is now causing serious image problems for businesses, as the media and outside groups shine a light on the questionable behaviour of a tiny number of people in this world. Senior executives might conclude the public pain this caused them was worth it if it secured the right decisions from politicians. But it has never been clear such an approach worked in the first place.
Ahead of every Budget, there always seems to be a group of businesspeople that believe their discreet, “constructive” approach to public affairs will have secured them a good deal from government. Every year this group of people ends up disappointed.
The simple reality is this: most politicians only respond to pressure. Look at it from their point of view. Their entire career is dependent on the perception they are doing a good job. They need the Prime Minister to promote them and their constituency to re-elect them at the next election. Any serious public criticism has the potential to send them straight back to obscurity.
The negative coverage surrounding the public affairs industry should provide a wake-up call to senior business executives. Involvement in traditional lobbying is not only bad for their reputation, but it is mostly irrelevant too. Businesses should take a completely different approach, and this should come in two parts.
First, and most importantly, businesses that want to influence decision-making within government or party policy formulation should replace lobbyists with campaigners to generate major public conversations around the issues that matter to them. They should make their case aggressively to secure public support that will, in turn, pressure elected politicians to make the right choices.
The growth of the web makes this prospect seriously viable for virtually any organisation for the first time. For example, they can use opinion research to work out exactly which audiences are most enthusiastic about their cause, use microtargeted social media advertising to grow their campaign base, and then create an online platform that helps people to air their views. And the success they achieve can then be marketed back into the mainstream media. Campaigns along these lines are developing widely in the US and should come to prominence in the UK.
Secondly, businesses (and other organisations) need to come to an agreement with the government – and realistically the media and the public – over greater transparency. A statutory register for lobbyists now looks inevitable. Those engaged in communications and public affairs should ensure this is targeted squarely at those who seek to affect decision-making through direct contact with government and Parliament, leaving the campaign and PR world encouraged to operate without interference.
Many that operate in public affairs may initially be worried about replacing their quiet approach with one that is above the line and direct. However, they will find not only that operating in full public view removes virtually all the discomfort surrounding lobbying, but that they are also more likely to achieve what they want in policy terms. No politician with a brain is going to ignore campaigns that tap into the public mood successfully, and many will welcome the opportunity to go along with something that looks popular.
James Frayne is a communications adviser and a former director of communications in government.
In other news
FORMER trader Tom Hayes was fired in 2010, four years after he started attempting to manipulate Libor, according [Read more]
SOCIAL media giant Twitter is in talks with Flipboard, to buy the media curation mobile app.
Charter Communications has finalised its $55bn (£36bn) takeover of Time Warner Cable. [Read more]
A smart approach to risk-taking, a curious mind which is also capable of intense focus, as well as dogged determination [Read more]
Maintaining the heavy duty escalators and lifts which support London's tube network is a mammoth task - and this [Read more]
This year 17 women aged under 45 made it onto Forbes' annual list of the World's 100 most powerful women. [Read more]
An anti-austerity protest has been organised to coincide with the Queen's Speech tomorrow, with campaigners targeting [Read more]
Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis has said it could impose a small levy on bank ATM withdrawals to encourage [Read more]
Central London roads were gridlocked this afternoon as the black cab protest caused chaos around Parliament Square, [Read more]
Chief executives at media and tech giants are coining it in, accounting for eight out of the top 10 best-paid [Read more]
Friends, flatmates and family of TfL staff are currently able to use London's public transport for free, but the [Read more]
The euro tumbled to a one-month low against the dollar this morning with investors unable to shake-off concerns [Read more]
We're seeing a renaissance; it’s incredibly exciting. People are better educated and the market is growing and [Read more]
Over the course of June, Greece must make four payments totalling €1.6bn (£1.1bn) to the IMF, starting with [Read more]
BlackBerry has announced that it will make job cuts as it consolidates.