How they rated England

Glen Johnson 5
A threat going forward but otherwise sloppy, particularly when passing

Leighton Baines 6
Made one great clearance to deny Ukraine and was tidy, but hardly impressive

Steven Gerrard 6
Passed well and made a vital clearance but ruined it with his deserved dismissal

Jermain Defoe
Unlucky to have what looked a good goal disallowed but England still needed more

Phil Jagielka 5
Like Lescott, Jagielka gave the ball away. Was Gary Cahill the better choice?

James Milner 6
Typically worked hard and almost scored but his threat was not regular enough

A Oxlade-Chamberlain 6
Provided a good, enthusiastic option for England but is capable of more

Roy Hodgson 5
Hodgson’s uninspiring substitutions failed to change an uninspiring result

Joe Hart 7
Hart could do little about Ukraine’s impressive goal and did little else wrong

Joleon Lescott 5
Lescott always looked uncomfortable with Ukraine’s pace and movement

Frank Lampard 7
Encouragingly always wanted the ball and scored England’s penalty

Tom Cleverley 4
Missed three good chances and was largely responsible for the poor result

Substitutes
Danny Welbeck (Cleverley, 62) 7, big threat; Daniel Sturridge (Oxlade-Chamberlain, 69) 5, pace but no inspiration; Ryan Bertrand (Baines, 73) 5, an unnecessary change