Charities take the burden as parties harden on welfare
14 December 2012 1:21am
ONCE upon a time, we had to read the old classics to hear about the two kinds of people in need – the labouring poor and the undeserving poor. Dickensian scenes of the hard-working Bob Cratchit, abused by his employer Scrooge, contrasted with the feckless, drunken Bill Sykes.
But is it too far fetched to say we’re heading back in this direction? Attitudes have hardened, with sympathy for those on benefits dwindling. And not surprisingly, George Osborne has capitalised on this shift and grasped it firmly to his austerity chest – slashing housing, unemployment and disability benefits. In the Autumn Statement, he pegged the increase in benefits to just 1 per cent each year for the next three years, despite expectations that real wages for those in work, and inflation, will increase by more. As the economist Jonathan Portes shows, many benefits have been falling relative to average earnings for more than 30 years, despite a slight recent upturn as private sector wages stagnated. But that’s not what the public think.
Such a world makes politics difficult, especially for Labour. It feels uncomfortable with the idea that those on low incomes should bear so much of the strain of the current fiscal squeeze. After all, the banking debacle that led to the need for austerity had little to do with them.
Ed Miliband rightly feels he is on firm ground when he questions the cutting of benefits for those in work – the strivers and the squeezed middle. But even Labour is unsure of its touch on benefits for those out of work. Osborne’s characterisation of them as lying in bed may be misleading. But to be found on the wrong side of the vicious atmosphere on scroungers is a dangerous place to be if you want to win elections.
In such a world, the question may soon be asked, if the state under either party is not willing to care for them, who will look after the “undeserving” poor?
Perhaps this will be the future role for charity and philanthropists. For many decades, this sector felt it added value to a fairly comprehensive welfare state by filling in some gaps, funding innovation and supporting new causes. Maybe in the future, however, we will need to look to the modern equivalents of Joseph Rowntree and George Peabody to actually provide any services at all for those at the bottom of the pile.
Already many “unpopular” causes only survive by getting help from charitable organisations and sources – support for prisoners, asylum seekers, and those with severe mental health problems. Since we will always have those who cannot get by in modern society, perhaps it will fall to real charity and faith-based groups to once again support them.
Some may think this a desirable state of affairs – ending forever the moral hazard associated with the welfare system. But many of us, sitting in our warm homes with the turkey roasting, will feel that while Dickensian is a nice atmospheric phrase, it is not one we expected to see lived out again in our lifetime.
Dan Corry is chief executive of New Philanthropy Capital and a former adviser to Gordon Brown.
In other news
An anti-austerity protest has been organised to coincide with the Queen's Speech tomorrow, with campaigners targeting [Read more]
Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis has said it could impose a small levy on bank ATM withdrawals to encourage [Read more]
Central London roads were gridlocked this afternoon as the black cab protest caused chaos around Parliament Square, [Read more]
Chief executives at media and tech giants are coining it in, accounting for eight out of the top 10 best-paid [Read more]
Friends, flatmates and family of TfL staff are currently able to use London's public transport for free, but the [Read more]
The euro tumbled to a one-month low against the dollar this morning with investors unable to shake-off concerns [Read more]
We're seeing a renaissance; it’s incredibly exciting. People are better educated and the market is growing and [Read more]
Over the course of June, Greece must make four payments totalling €1.6bn (£1.1bn) to the IMF, starting with [Read more]
BlackBerry has announced that it will make job cuts as it consolidates.
If we wanted to get rid of every MP who had ever told a porkie, "we'd clear out the House of Commons very fast", [Read more]
A spooky new game has taken over Twitter – but what is the Charlie Charlie challenge all about? [Read more]
John Healey, the former Labour housing minister and shadow health secretary, has announced he is running to be [Read more]
Online streaming may be on the rise, but the lure of the silver screen is still strong if Cineworld's last 19 [Read more]