Britain’s healthcare system is on the critical list – why are medical unions in denial?
26 January 2012 12:05am
IT REALLY is time public sector unions stopped taking the lazy option. And those representing the medical profession, above all, should be showing the rest of their comrades leadership – for decisions made over the nation’s healthcare are a matter of life and death.
Yet the doctors’ union is threatening to strike over the current pensions offer, while the nurses and midwives unions are both opposing the coalition’s NHS reforms. It is time to face facts. In the name of patient care and professional integrity, unions are a million miles from where they should be on both these issues.
On pensions, the status quo is not viable. These pensions are underfunded to a staggering extent. Doctors pay in only 8.5 per cent of their salary, while the cost to the taxpayer of the employers’ contribution is equivalent to more than 40 per cent. Even under the government’s current plans, doctors’ contributions will only rise to 14.5 per cent.
Someone has to pay for these pensions. It seems unions still haven’t woken up to the fact that the government has no money of its own. It is the private sector that will end up footing the bill for the shortfall in the pensions of these already very handsomely-paid doctors. More important still, the degree of underfunding is such that future generations of the private sector will also have to help pay off these obligations. At a time when private sector workers are facing tougher pension conditions, they are effectively being hit twice.
On NHS reforms the situation is just as bad. The current NHS structure is simply not delivering. International comparisons reveal that medical outcomes are dreadful, despite spending rises and the exemption of the health budget from the cuts. Structural reform is long overdue.
We now spend over 8 per cent of GDP on health. It is the second-largest area of expenditure for the government after welfare. Yet in the developed world’s league tables we fare appallingly. One study by the Taxpayers’ Alliance estimates that compared to other European countries an extra 12,000 deaths occur a year in the UK due to inferior healthcare. We have poor cancer survival rates and comparatively high deaths from circulatory disease. Data from overseas suggest that either European-style, insurance-based funding or, better still, a savings account system as in Singapore would produce better health outcomes at a lower cost.
In the face of these statistics, change is both inevitable and essential: we have a system we cannot afford and that doesn’t work. Across the health service, we have lost sight of the people it is meant to be there for – the patients. Quality has declined and it is time we found ways of bringing in more accountability and putting the people it is there to serve back at the heart of its mission. This means structural reform, and on a much more radical level than the coalition is talking about.
Changing how the NHS is funded can be only part of this. The way the medical profession works must also be modernised. Central pay bargaining and the negotiation of pension arrangements at a centralised level is not conducive to creating a workforce that cares or performs to the best of its abilities. There should be much more differentiated pay across the sector and regions.
We also need to consider ways to deregulate healthcare to improve competition. At the moment the centralised nature of the system means that only 17 per cent of healthcare funding in the UK is private. There are all kinds of restrictive practices, for instance the systems by which doctors are licensed, that make it hard for private providers to compete fairly. The nature of the current system also creates ill-feeling towards the private sector, as there is not enough competition to drive down private prices.
In the face of these great national issues, medical unions are refusing to engage. They should be the very ones leading the charge for constructive reform on all these issues, preserving the future of their profession and improving the quality of its work. They should be proposing a sensible and reasonable model for reform to the structure of the NHS, as well as to pay. Yet where is an alternative from unions that will deliver for patients? Where is their comparative study of insurance models across Europe or of the impact of health savings accounts?
Unions must grasp the reality of the crisis we face. Innovative thinking in healthcare is in the interests of both patients and medical professionals. What a tragedy then, that it is unimaginable for Britain’s doctors to be in the vanguard of improving our broken system.
Ruth Porter works for the Institute of Economic Affairs (iea).
Compared to Europe, bad healthcare causes 12,000 extra UK deaths a year.
In other news
Sepp Blatter will be Fifa president for a further four years after comfortably beating Prince Ali Bin Al-Hussein [Read more]
Ukip's Lord Pearson of Rannoch has asked the government to back a draw Mohammed competition. [Read more]
Network Rail and RMT bosses are once again entering talks to see if the latest set of strikes, announced yesterday, [Read more]
IMF chief Christine Lagarde said this morning that a comprehensive deal with Greece is "very unlikely... in the next few days". [Read more]
Good news multiple-gun salute fans. Next week there will be not one but two such events, marking the 62nd year [Read more]
An EasyJet flight from Luton to Tel Aviv has been forced to turn back after multiple cabin crew members reported [Read more]
A vehicle has struck a bridge it was passing under in Tulse Hill, south London, causing train cancellations and [Read more]
Shares in troubled insurance claims outsourcer Quindell fell in late morning trading after the company announced [Read more]
After a number of top Fifa officials were arrested on accusations of bribery and racketeering this week, the already [Read more]
The mother of the children who died at a Thomas Cook-approved hotel in Corfu has slammed Harriet Green's decision [Read more]
The meteoric rise in London office rents is unlikely to slow down for at least another year, the chief executive [Read more]
Andy Burnham will today admit that Labour got it wrong on business and the economy, and that the party cannot [Read more]
The German Chambers of Commerce and Industry has said it is “astonished” that the UK is considering leaving [Read more]
When it comes to creating new technologies, London is a long way behind other cities in the UK, new research has [Read more]
Four FinTech startups have won $100,000 (£65,400) backing from Citi after a search for new technology and innovation [Read more]
Property types may have been worried about the looming spectre of a mansion tax during the run-up to the General [Read more]
Corruption allegations, arrests of top officials, global outrage - in most organisations such calamities would [Read more]
Are the UK's new crop of MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Donmar Warehouse | ★★★★★ [Read more]
Olivier Theatre | ★★★☆☆
Kingfisher, Europe’s biggest home improvement retailer, said it has found buyers for a quarter of its stores [Read more]
Clothing retailer Abercrombie & Fitch said yesterday that its business is recovering, buoyed by the strong [Read more]
Just a handful of football clubs offer fans fast smartphone connections despite growing pressure to install the [Read more]
Business services firms are seeing a boom on a scale not experienced for almost a decade, with sales volumes rocketing [Read more]