Want to change behaviour? Try more markets, not more regulation
15 April 2014 9:33pm
ECONOMICS provides us with a really big insight into how the world works: people respond to changes in incentives. A great deal of public policy is based on this principle. Want fewer people to drive into Central London? Introduce a congestion charge and make it more expensive. It works.
In practice, of course, estimating exactly how much any given change in a particular incentive alters behaviour can be a difficult problem. Indeed, changing incentives can sometimes have unforeseen consequences, which may appear perverse.
A couple of months ago, a school in Milton Keynes proposed to fine parents £60 if their child was late more than 10 times in a term. We do not yet know how this has worked out, but a similar scheme in a day care centre in Israel seemed to backfire. After the fine had been introduced, there was a rise, not a fall, in the number of parents delivering their children late. People now knew the price of being late – the fine. They could then make judgements as to the value of the effort required to arrive on time compared to being tardy. Previously, they had only incurred the displeasure of the teacher.
A recent book by the Harvard political philosopher Michael Sandel cites this as an example of the intrinsic limits to the use of markets. Social norms, not incentives, matter. His book has metropolitan liberals both here and in the US gurgling with pleasure.
But the problem essentially arose not because of the limitations of markets, but because there were too few of them. Without a market, disapproval could not be priced transparently. Parents just had to guess what this was worth, and on average they clearly placed a higher price on it than the level of the fine set by the school. The school was also at fault for not increasing the fine by trial and error steps until it started to do its intended job.
More challenging is a study carried out by the Framework Institute in America on public attitudes towards global warming. How to Talk About Global Warming reported that substantial numbers of people, when faced with how they respond to more extreme weather, chose to buy a SUV to help them cope, rather than to support increases in fuel-efficiency standards.
The instinctive response of a regulator to this finding would be to say that these individuals only had access to incomplete information. With more and better information, they would then respond to incentives so that they made the “correct” choice. But more information does not necessarily help. Al Gore’s 2006 film about global warming An Inconvenient Truth received enormous publicity. But the number of Americans telling Gallup that the media was exaggerating global warming has grown from 34 per cent then to 42 per cent today.
A popular policy for avoiding a financial crisis is to restrict bankers’ bonuses, giving them different incentives. It may work. But understanding exactly how incentives operate in practice does not always have a pat solution.
Paul Ormerod is an economist at Volterra Partners, a visiting professor at the UCL Centre for Decision Making Uncertainty, and author of Why Most Things Fail: Economics, Evolution and Extinction.
In other news
BARCLAYS, the international London-based bank led by Antony Jenkins, has decided to put its broking mandate up [Read more]
BUSINESS groups largely welcomed yesterday’s Queen’s Speech, but many nevertheless identified concerns with [Read more]
Former Thomas Cook boss Harriet Green has said she'll donate a third of her forthcoming share award to a charity [Read more]
Update: Firefighters have put out a blaze at a Berkeley Homes building site on Arsenal Way, Woolwich this afternoon. [Read more]
Greece's creditors have poured cold water on the cash-strapped country's claim that the parties were nearing a [Read more]
The EU and Switzerland have signed a deal to stop EU residents holding undeclared income in Swiss bank accounts. [Read more]
A random combination of words and characters are automatically shutting down iPhone users' devices. [Read more]
London will play host to a record number of cyclists in August as the Prudential Ride London Freecycle event expands [Read more]
Commuters using London's Fenchurch Street could face a travel headache going home tonight, with operators confirming [Read more]
Eight candidates are vying for the role of deputy Labour leader in a crowded race alongside the high-profile leadership [Read more]
Between 1997 and 2013, people living in just four regions in the UK saw their disposable income increase when [Read more]
Prime Minister David Cameron has had work done. Five years in Coalition has taken its toll on the youthful fresh-face [Read more]
Swiss police are questioning 10 Fifa officials over the controversial award of the 2018 and 2022 World Cups to [Read more]
Dutch banking giant ING last night cut its stake in NN, an insurance and investment management company.
Update: Nearly 150 flights have been cancelled and 32 diverted to other European cities after a power outage shut [Read more]
A fresh investigation into migrant worker conditions in Qatar landed BBC reporters in prison recently. It is another [Read more]
The Bank of England will not back down on tough regulation, top official and ex-Barclays boss Martin Taylor said [Read more]
Perhaps the most enjoyable outcome of the General Election is the abuse now being heaped on the metropolitan liberal [Read more]
Private company SpaceX has received certified approval from the US to send military and spy satellites into space. [Read more]
Essex commuters will be the first to benefit from London’s Crossrail train service, with fare cuts of up to [Read more]