US debt ceiling division may be the harbinger of greater crises to come
10 October 2013 12:58am
AS THE government shutdown has metastasised into a crisis about the US debt ceiling, a dark narrative has been playing endlessly inside my head. For the social and political divisions that have been revealed over these past few weeks may well be harbingers of greater crises ahead.
To understand why, we need only look back to 1967. Even before the Summer of Love began, the peerless Buffalo Springfield, as ever ahead of the curve, was singing about its demise: “There’s somethin’ happenin’ here/ What it is ain’t exactly clear/ There’s a man with a gun over there/ A tellin’ me I got to beware/ I think it’s time we stop, children, what’s that/ Sound?/ Everybody look what’s going down.”
The ominous, prophetic single of February 1967, For What It’s Worth, was inspired by the previous November’s Sunset Strip riots in Los Angeles between police and local kids over a draconian curfew designed to put an end to the youth scene that was beginning to flourish. Both the song and the riot were a foretaste of the gaping divisions to come – over Vietnam, civil rights, and the generation gap.
Now, with the 17 October deadline inching into view – the date when the US could default if the debt ceiling is not raised by Congress – both sides have morphed into sullen teenagers. Barack Obama has said he will only negotiate over other issues when a clean bill raising the debt ceiling is passed, and House Republicans will only pass such a bill if Obama agrees in advance to negotiate over other issues. This would be funny if the consequences were not so dire.
The White House thinks it has little immediate incentive to let the Republicans up for air. The most recent poll numbers, published on 7 October, make it clear that House Republicans are hated for what they are doing (the Washington Post/ABC News poll has them with a negative 46 per cent approval differential), House Democrats are strongly disliked (negative 16), with the public finding the White House’s shenanigans only distasteful (negative 6). In the hateful shark tank of Washington politics, this constitutes a win for the President.
But he must be careful. As one commentator observed over the weekend, “Can anyone remember the name of the Speaker of the House in 1929?” Presidents, not Congress, are ultimately held accountable for the economy, however factually unreasonable that is. If the Obama administration really thinks an actual default will help them, they are even farther gone than I fear.
While it is easy (and correct) to blame the political pygmies in both parties, as Winston Churchill rightly observed you get what you deserve in a democracy. And here politics is merely following the American cultural bandwagon. For Washington isn’t doing this to the US people. Culturally, Americans in 45 of 50 states (despite what they say) like the present state of affairs, to the extent of continuing to vote for one-party governments at the state and local levels.
And as Charles Darwin realised, once self-selection starts, it is a very difficult process to stop. People with cosmopolitan, leftish views prefer living in New York City and San Francisco, where they know such points of view are favourably looked upon, just as those who cherish traditional American values like to live in places like Texas and Nebraska.
While this has always been true, intellectual flabbiness – the basic yearning not to be challenged by other views, but to instead cocoon oneself among news sources and neighbours that sustain one’s own prejudices – has taken this natural process an unnatural step further. A majority of the country finds itself surrounded by people of similar views, who just cannot understand how the other side can be so incredibly stupid. Why compromise with morons?
Yes, Goldman Sachs’s assessment that a failure to raise the ceiling could have immediate costs of 4.2 per cent of GDP is important, as is China’s exasperated plea that – as holders of $1.28 trillion of US debt – someone better remember that this process is unlikely to result in Beijing being terribly keen to buy more. Certainly, this act of political self-immolation would signify a dramatic reversal of fortune, with America transforming itself from leading the global economic recovery to being the primary millstone around the world’s neck.
But far worse, as Buffalo Springfield would recognise, this calamity would represent such a fraying of American society that its future political stability can no longer be complacently assumed by anyone. These are the real stakes of the events of the next few days, and they couldn’t be higher.
Dr John C Hulsman is president and co-founder of John C Hulsman Enterprises (www.john-hulsman.com), a political risk consultancy. He is a life member of the Council on Foreign Relations, and author of Ethical Realism, The Godfather Doctrine, and Lawrence of Arabia, To Begin the World Over Again.
In other news
Pharma giant GSK (aka GlaxoSmithKline) has abandoned plans for an IPO of its HIV medicines division, it said today. [Read more]
What happens if you spray unsuspecting spiders with graphene, the world's strongest artificial material? They [Read more]
The British trader accused of causing the U.S. 2010 flash crash cannot pay his £5m bail because U.S. authorities [Read more]
Fragments of a failed Russian spacecraft are expected to fall to Earth later this week, according to space agency [Read more]
With just one day left of campaigning, the polls indicate there's little between the main parties, which suggests the [Read more]
It's not hard to tell the difference between Skype and Sky. One's a Microsoft-owned text, voice and video messaging [Read more]
In the aftermath of the subprime mortgage crisis, you'd have thought lenders had learned their lessons - but perhaps [Read more]
Sales at discounters Aldi and Lidl grew 15 per cent and 10 per cent respectively in the past year, data published [Read more]
The last data released before the polls open tomorrow has shown services growth hit an eight-month high, potentially [Read more]
If you share a heartbeat and there's no one at the other end to feel it, has that heartbeat been shared at all? [Read more]
We all know staying on top of emails is a challenge, and that's without the added pressure of coming up with a [Read more]
Londoners spend 12 hours a day online, a new study suggests - three hours more than the average UK resident. [Read more]
Network Rail has confirmed there will be delays into and out of London Waterloo station until "at least 9.30am" [Read more]
This is supposed to be the "social election" - but are the UK's MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Pub and restaurant group Greene King yesterday blamed recently tightened drink-driving laws in Scotland for flat [Read more]
Bargain store Poundland has bought forward a competition probe into its offer to buy rival 99p Stores for £55m. [Read more]
It may be at a “great disadvantage” to supermarkets, but JD Wetherspoon still managed to report an increase [Read more]
It is difficult to believe that it was half a decade ago that Liam Byrne – a Treasury minister in Gordon Brown’s [Read more]
Shares in Salesforce.com jumped 6.2 per cent yesterday, after it was reported that Microsoft is considering [Read more]
Nick Clegg has warned that the country could be forced to hold a second election before Christmas, if his party [Read more]
The global economy risks slipping into a deflationary trap. The US recovery is built on shaky ground, the Eurozone [Read more]
Business has led the recovery in recent years, but this cannot be taken for granted. We need an environment that [Read more]
SHOP PRICES continued to fall in April, albeit at a slower pace, with food prices remaining at a record low for [Read more]