Lessons from Italy: What happens when businesses are forced to move abroad
26 September 2013 12:40am
THE 42 employees of Firem, an Italian heating systems maker, returned from their August holidays to find the plant where they worked had relocated to Poland. Firem is not the only recent Italian escape act. Italy’s entrepreneurs, facing the second-to-worst business climate in the developed word, on World Bank figures, are leaving. And union power and political patronage are making them do so stealthily.
Italy’s payroll taxes are the highest in the EU. Total taxation of business income is the second-highest. The government recently abolished a tax on first homes, but it is now drawing up plans to negate this by instituting a local service tax in the 2014 budget.
In total taxation, Italy ranks sixth in the EU. Sixth may not seem so terrible but, as Italians joke, they pay Danish taxes and get Italian services. Take the courts. The World Bank ranks Italy at 160 out of 185 nations, just above Afghanistan. Average claims take three and a half years to settle. One employee dismissal case took 11 years to conclude – and the employer paid back wages and severance throughout.
It’s no wonder that firms want to leave. And those that stay do not strive to grow, but remain within their own networks of employees, suppliers, and customers, often family or friends. Venturing out of the network isn’t worth the risk of having to go to court to fire a poorly-performing employee or enforce a delivery contract.
It’s one reason why unemployment is so dire, and the government isn’t helping. Despite official rates falling in line with EU averages of 8 to 10 per cent, we calculate unemployment to be 24.9 per cent, after accounting for discouraged employees and those receiving wages from the Cassa Integrazione Guadagni (CIG), a fund for “temporarily” furloughed workers.
Such a large number of unemployed should push wages lower, but national collective bargaining contracts prevent this from occurring. Such agreements set wages for entire industries, regardless of regional differences in living costs. Add professional licensing and stringent labour laws that block competition, and it’s not hard to see why businesses are fleeing – for lower taxes, less bureaucracy, and more flexible labour markets outside Italy.
Worse, firms have to run for the door when no one is looking. Unions occupy property to get their way, and politicians, beholden to union votes, discourage courts from sending in the police to disperse them. After five years of losses, Firem’s chief executive Fabrizio Pedroni saw an chance to save his company with a quick dash for the exit. He would have liked to inform his workers. But if he had, they would have occupied his factory and confiscated his equipment. Indeed, they tried to do just that, but only managed to seize a handful of trucks. Unions and local government “negotiated” with Pedroni: the plant will remain open but empty, save for a few administrative staff. Workers will receive a year of taxpayer-funded money-for-nothing from the CIG.
Italy spending money it doesn’t have won’t solve its runaway business problem. Politicians must get serious about reform. Otherwise Rome will keep waking up to find firms, and the jobs they create, vanished in the night.
Matthew Melchiorre is Warren T. Brookes journalism fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute. Emilio Rocca is research fellow at the Istituto Bruno Leoni. They are authors of The unintended consequences of Italy’s labour laws (Economic Affairs, 2013).
In other news
Emirates Airline has been confirmed as the new sponsor of the FA Cup on the day of the cup final which will see [Read more]
Newly re-elected Fifa president Sepp Blatter has given a press conference in Zurich where he answered the many [Read more]
Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the inventor of the World Wide Web, has warned of encroaching government powers after plans [Read more]
Sepp Blatter will be Fifa president for a further four years after comfortably beating Prince Ali Bin Al-Hussein [Read more]
Ukip's Lord Pearson of Rannoch has asked the government to back a draw Mohammed competition. [Read more]
Network Rail and RMT bosses are once again entering talks to see if the latest set of strikes, announced yesterday, [Read more]
IMF chief Christine Lagarde said this morning that a comprehensive deal with Greece is "very unlikely... in the next few days". [Read more]
Good news multiple-gun salute fans. Next week there will be not one but two such events, marking the 62nd year [Read more]
An EasyJet flight from Luton to Tel Aviv has been forced to turn back after multiple cabin crew members reported [Read more]
A vehicle has struck a bridge it was passing under in Tulse Hill, south London, causing train cancellations and [Read more]
Shares in troubled insurance claims outsourcer Quindell fell in late morning trading after the company announced [Read more]
After a number of top Fifa officials were arrested on accusations of bribery and racketeering this week, the already [Read more]
The mother of the children who died at a Thomas Cook-approved hotel in Corfu has slammed Harriet Green's decision [Read more]
The meteoric rise in London office rents is unlikely to slow down for at least another year, the chief executive [Read more]
Andy Burnham will today admit that Labour got it wrong on business and the economy, and that the party cannot [Read more]
The German Chambers of Commerce and Industry has said it is “astonished” that the UK is considering leaving [Read more]
When it comes to creating new technologies, London is a long way behind other cities in the UK, new research has [Read more]
Four FinTech startups have won $100,000 (£65,400) backing from Citi after a search for new technology and innovation [Read more]
Property types may have been worried about the looming spectre of a mansion tax during the run-up to the General [Read more]
Corruption allegations, arrests of top officials, global outrage - in most organisations such calamities would [Read more]
Are the UK's new crop of MPs actually any good at social media? [Read more]
Donmar Warehouse | ★★★★★ [Read more]
Olivier Theatre | ★★★☆☆
Kingfisher, Europe’s biggest home improvement retailer, said it has found buyers for a quarter of its stores [Read more]