Philip Hammond joins European finance ministers to call for a rethink of Trump's proposed US tax reform

 
Lucy White
President Trump Participates In A Tax Reform Industry Meeting In The Roosevelt Room Of The White House
Steven Mnuchin (left) has been in charge of formulating Trump's tax reform (Source: Getty)

Chancellor Philip Hammond has joined with his counterparts across Europe to urge US Secretary of the Treasury Steven Mnuchin to rethink a proposed tax reform.

In a letter addressed to Mnuchin, seen by City A.M., the finance ministers of the UK, Germany, France, Italy and Spain warned that the tax reform promised by President Donald Trump could break international rules and may risk "seriously hampering genuine trade and investment flows".

The ministers warned that the measures could "discriminate" in a manner which would contravene World Trade Organisation (WTO) provisions, would be inconsistent with double taxation rules, and would be "poorly targeted" at helping to combat tax avoidance.

Read more: Trump's tax reforms could shake up the global M&A environment, warns tax consultancy Taxand

"The inclusion of certain less conventional international tax provisions could contravene the US’s double taxation treaties and may risk having a major distortive impact on international trade," the letter stated.

Trump's set of changes, which has also divided opinion in the US, is currently being pushed through the legislative process.

One proposal provides for a 20 per cent excise tax on payments to foreign affiliated companies, which "would impact on genuine commercial arrangements". Because it would only apply where payments are being made for foreign goods and services, this would discriminate and break WTO rules.

Read more: Trump: I've got a corporate tax reform coming. It's the best corporate tax reform. It's just phenomenal.

The "base erosion and anti-abuse tax" (Beat), which is designed to prevent tax avoidance, has also raised concerns over its potential impact on the financial sector. Cross-border intra-group financial transactions would be treated as non-deductible from gross taxable income, and subject to a 10 per cent tax.

"This may lead to significant tax charges and may harmfully distort international financial markets," the European finance ministers wrote.

We also see the possibility that some of the proposed measures could constitute unfair trade practice and may discourage non-US financial institutions from operating in the US.

Yet another provision could constitute an illegal export subsidy under WTO rules, since it would reduce the tax payable on profit generated abroad through intellectual property.

The European finance ministers said that they were "confident" that Mnuchin would "find a wise and well-balanced compromise" when creating the new tax code, but urged him to bear their concerns in mind.

Read more: The progressives are cheating in the argument against Donald Trump’s tax cuts

Related articles