Apple analysts have let us down yet again

 
Steve Sedgwick
Follow Steve
New Apple iPhone X and New Apple Watch Go On Sale In Stores
The best analysts could offer us back in November was a “hold”. That is so mealy-mouthed (Source: Getty)

Apple analysts, huh, what are they good for? Absolutely nothing. Say it again...


Yep, that’s right, I just butchered one of the most powerful lyrics of the past 50 years. Lyrics immortalised by Edwin Starr in the 1970 Vietnam protest song, but for me it kind of grabs your attention and makes the point rather succinctly.

This may be a sweeping damnation of the analyst community’s performance regarding the tech giant, but I’m going to try to avoid repeating all the details of the Apple demise story.

In short, a precipitous fall has taken it from being worth circa $1.2 trillion to its current more modest $700bn valuation, leaving many of us who remember Nokia at its peak wondering if we will see history repeating itself so speedily.

What I want you to think about is the absolute “shock” experienced by the analysts regarding Apple’s revenue warning last week.


I want you to consider how many of the Wall Street analysts covering Apple had an outright “sell” or even an “underweight” on the stock?

Now, my Reuters analytics may be malfunctioning terribly but I’ve been watching Apple’s stock pretty keenly for years now, and in advance of last week’s warning, there were – wait for it – zero sells out there on the stock. Not one. As of 27 December, Apple had 13 “strong buy” ratings from analysts, 10 “buy”, and 20 “hold” ratings, with no “sell” or “strong sell” ratings.

Anyone else feeling a little let down by the objectivity of this motley crew? Let down, yes. But not surprised.

They herded, scared of being on the wrong side of perhaps the greatest of the Faangs (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix and Alphabet’s Google), scared of leaving the pack and actually watching what was going on.

Even we humble, lightweight business TV anchors spotted that there were big problems after the company pulled its individual iPhone sales figures from future reporting back in November.

Let me reiterate again, I’m not saying that Apple isn’t still a great company. I’m just pointing out the bleeding obvious.

There are times when even fantastic companies have hiccups, when their stock is overvalued, when it’s time to get out and cash in your chips and find a new entry point.

But not for analysts. The best they could offer us back in November was a “hold”. That is so mealy-mouthed. If a stock is a sell, say so. That’s what you are paid a lot of money for: objectivity. Maybe even add some versatility into your call if a stock has gone one way for years.

None of them will apologise. They will find some excuse for Apple’s underperformance, but what is worse in many ways is that now they are all there with their red marker pens, scything their valuations.

It’s too late though, your clients have lost vast amounts of money following your expert advice. What a waste.

City A.M.'s opinion pages are a place for thought-provoking views and debate. These views are not necessarily shared by City A.M.